<Go Back>

Response to "The Lottery"

It』s not about right or wrong.  It』s just different

Anton

     When we judge other people by their actions most of the time, we do not realize how narrow-minded we ourselves are.  For example, in the short story, 「The Lottery」, the town folks stoned Mrs. Hutchinson to death at the end.  Readers might consider the villagers cruel to have kept this tradition.  Yet, perhaps the town folks did not think so at all, because that was one part of their culture.  They were merely asking for an abundant harvest in the coming year with the ritual of stoning.  This issue brings out an ambiguous question.  How could we decide what is right or wrong?

     Prejudice plays an important role while we are trying to decide between right and wrong for prejudice usually leads us to consider one issue as purely negative.  It would be much more objective if we look at every event from different perspectives.  Or, if we could put our feet into someone else』s boots that would also help us avoid prejudices.  The recent debate about Jin, Mei-Ling (金美齡), for example, polarized the people: one group of people (they are the majority) fiercely oppose her idea of Independence of Taiwan, while the other support her.  The difference in opinion is so sensitive that it flares up people』s emotions whenever she is mentioned.  But if both groups would be willing to calm down and look at this issue from a different angle, for example, perhaps 「Mrs. Jin was merely offering her personal opinion about Taiwan」 and her idea is different from ours; then maybe the situation will cool down quickly. 

     In this day and age, we need to be more open-minded, especially when we are faced with so many different choices and ways of looking at the world.  Undoubtedly, there are many things we』ve never seen or imagined before, which our ignorance and narrow-mindedness will quickly describe as wrong.  Yet the same is true when other races of people look at us.  Considering all these possibilities, we need to recognize that there is nothing completely right or wrong, it is just a difference in opinion.

<Go Back>