<Go Back>

Response to "The Lottery"

Taking Cruelty for Granted

PeiJuan

    From ancient times to the present, there have always been some cruel and inhuman things existing in the society.  People rarely tried to stop this kind of cruelty; instead, they always take it for granted.  Moreover, many think that』s a good entertainment in their routinized life so that they can have fun through these activities.

Take Shirley Jackson』s 「The Lottery」 for example.  Inhabitants in the village held the ritual to hope for a great harvest.  They chose a person to accomplish the ceremony and at last Mrs. Hutchinson was selected to be the sacrifice.  They stoned her to death and thought that was fun.  No matter how Mrs. Hutchinson shouted, they ignored her; they insisted on carrying out the ritual.  Maybe the original purpose of the ritual had been to pray for a great harvest, but in the end, it became such a kind of cruelty.

There used to be an activity like 「The Lottery」 in the Roman Empire.  In ancient Rome, there were always some battles between two countries.  And the winner would grab some captives and take them to the amphitheater to fight fierce animals.  If he won the fight, he could survive; if he lost, he would become the animal』s food.  There was no denying that these captives had only one idea: to win; but they didn』t have much choice anyway.  This kind of activity would attract a lot of local citizens and they were excited about the action.  They never thought that was an inhuman thing.  They only thought of it as an entertainment for them, just like the village people in 「The Lottery.」  Even today, a similar sentiment exists in Taiwan. When the 921 earth quake happened, some people didn』t take pity on the victims.   Instead, they took pleasure watching the scene of disaster without caring whether they would hinder the rescue efforts.  In their opinion, it was a spectacle that they simply could not miss.

In all these three cases, people take cruelty for granted; therefore, they never show any sympathy for the victims.  Why do they neglect the human suffering?  Maybe people are always selfish.  But I believe it is compassion, the ability to think for others, that makes us human.

<Go Back>